What if these walls could talk? They would tell tales of faith community and transformation at the Eastern Presbyterian Church. This church once stood proudly at 609 Maryland Avenue NE. It was a beacon of hope in Capitol Hill.
Eastern Presbyterian Church’s story began in the early 1890s. It served as a place of worship for many years. In 1956, it was sold marking a new chapter in its history.
Over the years, Eastern Presbyterian Church became home to various religious congregations. Then, in 2015, Morning Star Community Development purchased the property. Their vision was to breathe new life into the historic structure.
Instead of demolishing the church, they chose to convert it into high-end condos. This project sought to preserve a landmark. It aimed to create something new without erasing the past. The renovation earned a 2019 District of Columbia Award for Excellence in Historic Preservation.
The architect Appleton P. Clark Jr. designed the Eastern Presbyterian Church in the Romanesque Revival style. Its tower earned it the nickname “The Lighthouse on the Hill.” President Woodrow Wilson and his family attended Easter services here in 1913.
The conversion resulted in six unique condos. Each unit ranged from 2293 to 2765 square feet. They were designed as three-story townhomes with elevators. High-end finishes and appliances completed the luxurious feel.
The developers meticulously restored the stained-glass windows. This process alone took 18 months. They represent the church and its history. Sunlight streaming through them creates amazing reflections inside.
One unique feature is the light fixture in the tower. It replaced the original bell. A new spiral staircase leads to this private common space for condo owners. Here, residents can enjoy 360-degree views of Washington DC.
Even the existing structural elements were reused creatively. The developers retained every historic element possible. This included a common wine cellar for residents.
Living in a former church is not for everyone. But the developers have received overwhelmingly positive reactions. People appreciate the blend of vintage exterior and modern interior.
Today, the former Eastern Presbyterian Church stands as a testament to innovative preservation. It reminds us that history can be reimagined. A building’s story can continue in new and unexpected ways.