Former Saint James United Methodist Church

The Former Saint James United Methodist Church is more than just a beautiful building standing here on South Ellis Avenue. It’s a testament to a rich history, a community’s resilience, and a commitment to racial integration. Built in 1925, the Former Saint James United Methodist Church replaced an earlier building destroyed by fire. Designed by prominent Chicago architects Tallmadge and Watson, the limestone church with its towering, six-story cathedral became a focal point in the Kenwood neighborhood. In the mid-20th century, the congregation made a bold decision to embrace the changing neighborhood demographics. With the rise of racial tensions, many churches moved out of changing communities. Not Saint James. They chose to open their doors to their new Black neighbors. This act of integration was celebrated in a 1960s article in the Chicago Defender, underscoring the significance of this decision. The congregation shared space with the YMCA to offer programs for neighborhood children, a commitment that cemented their place in the community. As the community shifted, so did the church’s needs. Despite its historic significance and legacy, the building fell into disrepair and became too expensive to maintain. In 2010, the congregation closed and merged with Hartzell Memorial United Methodist Church. The magnificent Casavant Frères pipe organ, a testament to the church’s musical heritage, was even relocated to St. John Cantius Catholic Church. The church remained vacant until a developer acquired it in 2016. Today, the Former Saint James United Methodist Church still stands. A new chapter unfolds as it is being repurposed into apartments and a co-working space. The past is cherished, and a new chapter in this historic building begins.