“Another synagogue?” you might ask. But the Mill Hill Synagogue has a unique story to tell. This Orthodox synagogue in Mill Hill has been a cornerstone of the community since its founding in 1949. Its story is one of growth, adaptation and unwavering community spirit.
The Mill Hill Synagogue’s journey began humbly. Early services were held in a private house at 584 Watford Way. In 1952, the congregation purchased Whyteleafe, an old house on Sylvan Avenue for £7500. This marked a significant step. Whyteleafe was converted into a synagogue and consecrated in 1955. The location is a corner plot extending from Sylvan Close along Station Road. It backs onto Brockenhurst Gardens.
The congregation quickly outgrew its space. In 1959, a temporary prefabricated building was erected in Brockenhurst Gardens. This cost approximately £15000. It served as a multi-purpose synagogue and community center. The building included a synagogue hall, classrooms and offices. This temporary building was consecrated on 15th May 1960. Dayan Swift officiated and inducted Reverend Shlomo Cutler as Minister. Membership had grown to 238 families and 38 female members.
Originally intended for a 25-year lifespan, this temporary structure served the community for over 50 years. In 1975, it was remodeled as the Samuel Levy Hall. Later, in 1990, it was reconsecrated as the Annie and Samuel Levy Hall. The hall hosted High Holyday services, Cheder, kindergarten and various communal activities. These included a vibrant youth club and a popular Jewish Bridge Club. The Friendship Club and JACS club also met there.
Social activities flourished. New Year’s Eve dinner dances, barn dances and quizzes filled the calendar. The Mannickins audience participation shows became legendary. There were also racing nights, poker evenings and film shows. Weddings, bar/bat mitzvah celebrations and Chanukah parties added to the joyous atmosphere. The Ladies Guild prepared weekly Shabbat kiddushim.
A particularly poignant moment occurred during the Yom Kippur War in 1973. The community united to support Israel. Hearts and purses opened in an unparalleled display of solidarity. The Mill Hill Synagogue has always maintained close ties with Israel. Many members have made aliyah or own holiday homes there. The synagogue’s Israel Committee organizes fact-finding missions.
In the late 1960s, the community embarked on an ambitious project. They resolved to erect a purpose-built synagogue on the site of the original house. This new building would seat over 400 members. John Katten, a member of the community and an architect, designed the three-story building. It included a synagogue, ladies’ gallery, beis hamedrash, classrooms and offices. The total cost was approximately £35000. The United Synagogue provided a loan.
The new synagogue was consecrated on 28th November 1971. Chief Rabbi Dr. E. Jakobovits graced the occasion. Mr Bertie Webber, who was presented with its Golden Key, formally opened the building.
In 1993, Rabbi Cutler retired. Rabbi Schochet succeeded him ushering in a new era. The congregation celebrated its Golden Jubilee in 1999. Today, the Mill Hill Synagogue continues to thrive. It stands as a testament to the enduring power of community and faith. From humble beginnings in a private home to its current prominent location on Station Road, the Mill Hill Synagogue remains a vital part of London’s Jewish community.