Established in 1871 the Woodmere-Lawrence Methodist Church stands before you a testament to faith and community. It began as the Lawrence Methodist Church. Members decided to build a church in Samuel Wood’s village of Woodsburgh. A humble structure 25×40 feet it cost just $1583.28. Twenty months later in November 1872 it opened its doors. This wasn’t just any church. It was a beacon of hope in a growing community.
The Woodmere-Lawrence Methodist Church wasn’t always this one building. In 1889 under Reverend Alex McNicholl it expanded. Further improvements followed over the years. In 1897 a fund was started for a parsonage. The church continued to grow. Its membership increased from 84 to 122. 169 were baptized there. It merged with McKendres Chapel in 1976 becoming Woodmere-Lawrence United Methodist Church.
The Woodmere-Lawrence Methodist Church wasn’t just a place of worship. It was a hub of activity. It hosted suppers and events. It fostered a sense of belonging among its members. This close-knit community shared laughter and faith within its walls. Sadly dwindling membership led to its closure in June 2012. The church building sat vacant. It was then purchased by the United Hebrew Community of New York. This sparked some controversy in the community. Sadly the stained glass windows were reportedly damaged during demolition.
These windows were more than just glass. They were historical artifacts. They represented the church’s history and the community’s heritage. The destruction of these windows caused a significant backlash. People expressed disappointment and anger. The Woodmere-Lawrence Methodist Church may be gone but its legacy lives on. It’s a reminder of the importance of community and faith. Its story continues to resonate. Its memory is preserved in the hearts and minds of those who once worshipped within its walls. Even though it is now a part of history its spirit endures.