Picture this. A grand church stands before you. It’s the Westside Methodist Church a beacon of community and faith on the Upper West Side. Its history is rich a tapestry woven with threads of social justice music and unwavering devotion.
For over a century this wasn’t just a place of worship. It was a vibrant hub for the neighborhood. The Westside Methodist Church originally began as St Paul’s Methodist Church. It was completed in 1897. This magnificent structure designed by Robert H Robertson has witnessed countless milestones. From joyous weddings to somber funerals its walls have echoed with the prayers and songs of generations.
In the 1930s and 40s its large sanctuary often overflowed with worshippers. The church services were renowned for their talented vocal quartet. Even famed Metropolitan Opera soprano Eleanor Steber once graced its stage. The congregation thrived. A bustling 20-30 Club for young adults filled the building with energy. But as the decades passed the neighborhood shifted. Many families moved to the suburbs. The Westside Methodist Church faced challenges. Membership dwindled. The church faced closure.
However the remaining congregants refused to give up. They decided to turn outward. They embraced their community. This became the church’s rebirth. They started numerous outreach programs. The West Side Campaign Against Hunger began in a small church cupboard. Today it serves thousands of families each month. During the COVID-19 pandemic the church sanctuary transformed. It became a vital emergency food warehouse. This showed the church’s adaptability and unwavering commitment to its community.
The Westside Methodist Church also championed immigrants. In 1963 it launched its first Spanish-language ministry. A dual-language Sunday School and a Homework Help program continue to serve Spanish-speaking children. The church bravely offered sanctuary to a Central American family facing deportation. This brought national and international attention.
The Westside Methodist Church fostered interfaith relationships. It partnered with Congregation B’nai Jeshurun. They shared the sanctuary for High Holy Day services. The church shared space with other faith communities. A banner in the sanctuary proclaims “How good it is when brothers and sisters dwell together in harmony”. This reflects the spirit of inclusivity at the heart of the church.
The church’s West End Theatre hosted numerous productions. Even the Broadway show Bubbling Brown Sugar premiered there. Many films and TV shows have also used the church as a filming location. Today the theatre is managed by the Bedlam Theatre Company. The church supports the arts.
In recent years the church led social justice movements. It became a Reconciling Congregation. It welcomed and affirmed LGBTQ+ individuals. Members participated in protests against anti-queer legislation. It consistently advocates for equality and justice.
The Westside Methodist Church continues to inspire. It mentors progressive Christian leaders. People from St Paul & St Andrews serve communities worldwide. It’s a testament to the power of faith hope and community. As we stand here today remember this place is not merely a building. It’s a living testament to a community’s resilience its compassion and its enduring spirit.