Picture this a grand building standing proudly on Arlington Avenue. This is Temple Sinai of Brooklyn a place steeped in history and faith. Founded in 1886 as Congregation Bikur Cholim it initially met in a repurposed church on Wyona Street. The congregation was primarily made up of German Jewish immigrants. They chose a building formerly used by the East New York Reformed Church and then the Trinity Episcopal Church. Can you imagine the transformations this building underwent?
In 1920-1921 Temple Sinai constructed a new home at 24 Arlington Avenue. This marked a significant step for the growing community. They renamed themselves Temple Sinai signifying a new chapter in their history. The dedication of the new building was a momentous occasion. The original building on Wyona Street served them well for many years. This building was affectionately known as the Wyona Street Temple. This was a common practice referring to synagogues by their location.
Temple Sinai played a vital role in the lives of its members. The Young Folks League a vibrant auxiliary group thrived within the congregation. The congregation purchased burial plots in Bayside Cemetery and Mount Judah Cemetery providing a final resting place for loved ones. This highlights their strong sense of community and tradition. The Temple held great importance for many generations of families.
Tragically Temple Sinai of Brooklyn closed its doors in 1986. It was the last remaining synagogue in East New York. The building was subsequently sold to a Spanish Pentecostal church. Even though it’s no longer a Jewish house of worship many elements remain. Jewish stars adorn stained-glass windows. The Ten Commandments in Hebrew still appear above the pulpit. These details are a testament to the rich heritage of Temple Sinai.
Today while the building serves a different purpose the memories and legacy of Temple Sinai endure. It remains a powerful symbol of the Jewish community in East New York. The story of Temple Sinai demonstrates faith resilience and the enduring spirit of a community. It’s a reminder of the significant contributions of Jewish immigrants to Brooklyn’s rich tapestry.