A unique star they call it. The Church of Saint Catherine of Genoa. Right here on West 153rd Street. It stands as a testament to faith and community. A golden-hued brick beacon in Hamilton Heights.
Established in 1887 the parish initially held services in a movie theater. Imagine the contrast. A temporary space before this beautiful structure was built. It was a vibrant period for Irish immigrants. They formed the core of the early congregation. Today the congregation reflects the neighborhood’s diversity. African Americans Puerto Ricans Dominicans and Haitians all worship here. Services are held in English Spanish French and Haitian Creole.
Construction of Saint Catherine of Genoa Church lasted from 1889 to 1890. Architect Thomas H. Poole designed it in an eclectic style. Note its wide crow-stepped gable. See the ogee-headed openings. This unique facade is similar to his design for Our Lady of Good Counsel. A deep porch sheltered by a bracketed entryway welcomes you. The AIA Guide to New York City called it a unique star of Hamilton Heights. That’s quite a compliment.
The church’s history includes more than just its stunning architecture. A parish school run by the Sisters of Mercy opened in 1910. In 1937 a new four-story brick schoolhouse was built. It was designed by Jules Lewis. The school eventually closed in 2006. Now it houses P.S. 226. The rectory next door was built around 1926. It’s a quiet neighbor to the bustling church.
The organ inside Saint Catherine of Genoa Church is a story unto itself. Originally built in 1893 it was later moved from the Minneapolis studio of J. Warren Andrews. It has undergone alterations over the years. Some water damage was reported in 2013. Despite some modifications it remains playable. This instrument adds another layer to the rich history of this special place.
Saint Catherine of Genoa Church is more than just a building. It’s a vibrant community center. A place of worship and a historical landmark. A unique star indeed. It continues to serve its parishioners. It reflects the changing face of New York City. Its story is one of resilience faith and community. A story waiting to be explored further.