“Oldest public burial ground” Isn’t that a fascinating title? Welcome to the Reformed Church on Staten Island Cemetery. Here lies a place steeped in history. It is a testament to Staten Island’s early Dutch settlers.
The Reformed Church on Staten Island was founded in 1660. But its current Greek Revival building dates back to 1844. The adjacent cemetery is even older. It is the oldest non-private cemetery on Staten Island. This hallowed ground tells tales of families who shaped this island.
Imagine this: The graveyard possibly started as a private burial ground. It was for the Corson family in the 1690s. By 1705, it was known simply as “the burying place”. It became the final resting place for most North Shore families during the 1700s. The Reformed Church acquired more land in the 1800s. This expansion ensured ample burial space.
Take a closer look at the cemetery. It is divided into three sections. The northern section is the oldest. It holds the original public burial ground. Notice the brown and red sandstone grave markers. These are attributed to New Jersey stone carvers. One notable marker belongs to Mary Van Pelt. She died in 1746 at age 15. Her marker features a winged death’s head. This style is associated with the “Common Jersey Carver”. Ebenezer Price also has work here. He was a prominent 18th-century stonecutter.
The southern section was donated by Daniel Tompkins in 1816. Here lie members of the Tyson and Mersereau families. Also present are the Jacques, Sinclairs, Haughwouts, Crocherons, Housmans, and Posts. Part of this section now lies beneath the Sunday school wing. It was added in 1898. Some graves were moved, but several remain below.
Behind the Sunday school is the third section. The Reformed Church purchased this land in 1833. It was expanded in the 1870s. It provided space for future burials. Judge Jacob Tyson is buried here. He was a congressman and state senator. Family plots of the Van Name, Houseman, Drake, Kholer, and Post families are here.
The Reformed Church on Staten Island is still active. However, no interments have occurred here for over a century. Generations of Staten Islanders rest here. They are an integral part of the church’s and the island’s legacy. As you wander through this serene space reflect on the lives and stories etched in stone. This cemetery is a tangible link to Staten Island’s past. It is a reminder of the enduring spirit of community.