The majestic steeple of First Reformed Church of College Point pierces the sky. It stands proudly a testament to faith and resilience.
This isn’t just any church. The First Reformed Church of College Point holds a special place in New York City’s history. Founded in 1872 it’s one of the oldest surviving wooden churches in the city. Imagine the skilled hands of local builder E W Karker bringing this Carpenter-Gothic masterpiece to life. The church’s intricate decorative trim is a stunning example of its era.
Conrad Poppenhusen a prominent figure in College Point’s development generously donated $30000 to fund its construction. This was a significant contribution boosting the community’s spirit. The church wasn’t always located on 14th Avenue. In its early years 14th Avenue was known as First Avenue. This avenue informally divided College Point’s residential areas. Wealthier factory owners lived north of First Avenue. Factory workers occupied the more modest homes to the south.
The church’s early years saw several notable pastors. Rev ES Fairchild guided the congregation in its new building. He later transitioned to journalism becoming the head of the Flushing Times. Rev John Baumeister and Rev Frank Malven also served the church. Rev Malven’s departure in 1905 took him to a Presbyterian church in Pennsylvania. These pastors shaped the church’s identity leaving behind lasting legacies.
The church’s complex grew. A Sunday School building followed in 1881. Its Eastlake style showcased innovative machine-cut wooden trim a relatively recent invention. A parsonage was added in 1914. It’s an interesting detail that the church paid off its $4000 mortgage for the new parsonage in just one year. This speaks volumes about the community’s unwavering commitment.
In 1994 the church underwent a significant restoration. Sadly a fire in 2008 caused further damage. Yet the church persevered. Its 150th anniversary in June 2022 was a powerful testament to its enduring spirit. The First Reformed Church of College Point stands as a symbol of community resilience. Its story is one of faith perseverance and community spirit. Its dedication to service and worship continues to this day. The church remains an active part of College Point’s fabric a place where generations have found solace and spiritual guidance. The church complex is now listed on the National Register of Historic Places. This official recognition underscores its historical importance. It’s a treasure worth cherishing.