Remarkable isn’t it? This very spot houses the Duryea Presbyterian Church. A cornerstone of Prospect Heights its history is richer than you might imagine. Founded in 1887 as a mission church of Classon Avenue Presbyterian it was named for Reverend Joseph P Duryea the founder and first pastor of Classon Avenue. Initially located on Clermont Avenue near Atlantic Avenue the church quickly outgrew its space.
The Reverend John E Fray took the helm in 1893. He was known for his innovative methods. He famously used young women as ushers a move that drew both large crowds and some controversy. The church’s growth continued. However the noisy location near the LIRR and busy streets led to discussions about relocating. By 1902 the congregation began searching for a new home.
The church eventually purchased land at 185 Underhill Avenue. A beautiful Romanesque revival style church was constructed. The church was completed in 1905. Unfortunately a lightning strike in 1913 caused significant damage. The repairs were extensive and costly.
By 1929 under Reverend William G Clark-Duff the church considered an ambitious plan. They proposed a 15-story combined church and apartment building. This was an innovative idea. It would generate income for maintenance. The plan even included retail space on the ground floor. Local architect Murray Klein designed the proposed building. However the Great Depression ultimately stalled the project. The church decided against such a large undertaking. They opted instead for renovations and expansions to the existing building. The original domed steeple was removed. The auditorium was expanded. The interior underwent renovations.
The Duryea Presbyterian Church stands as a testament to adaptation and perseverance. Its history reflects the changing landscape of Prospect Heights. It’s a unique example of how a church navigated challenges. It shows its resilience even in the face of economic hardship. This building shows that faith can thrive even in unexpected ways. The church remains a vital part of the community a beacon of faith and history in the heart of Brooklyn.