“Snap” your fingers if you’re ready for a story about a true Natick landmark. This is Casey’s Diner. It stands as one of the oldest diners in Massachusetts. It may be the oldest in the entire United States.
Casey’s Diner is more than just a place to grab a bite. It’s a journey through time. It all began in 1890. Fred Casey purchased a horse-drawn wagon from the Brooks family. This wagon had just four stools.
Fast forward to 1922. The Worcester Lunch Car Company built the current diner. In 1927, Casey’s found its permanent home in downtown Natick. It has been serving generations ever since.
The diner is small and mighty. The building itself is only 10 by 20.5 feet. It was moved around some before finally ending up in Natick. It is tucked away on a side street at 36 South Avenue. You might miss it if you didn’t know it was here.
The diner’s exterior is distinctive. It boasts a metal barrel roof. Galvanized steel panels clad the structure. These panels are painted yellow. The diner sits on a concrete block foundation.
Inside Casey’s Diner, oak reigns supreme. The counter, stools, and ceiling are all crafted from this beautiful wood. Two original wooden doors welcome guests.
The menu at Casey’s Diner is full of tasty choices. But the star of the show is the steamed hot dog. It is famous for its “snap”. Order it “all around”. This means it comes with yellow mustard, relish, and chopped raw onions. All of this is placed under the hot dog in a steamed bun. There are also hamburgers and cheeseburgers. Sandwiches, chips, drinks, and pies are available. Breakfast hours have been introduced recently. A double cheeseburger was added to the menu as well. A Friday-only fish special is served.
Casey’s Diner has earned national recognition. Love Food named it one of the best classic diners in the country. It was also featured on the “Phantom Gourmet” television program.
The Casey family has owned the diner for four generations. It has passed down from father to son. Casey’s Diner even offers outdoor seating during warmer months.
This unassuming building holds a special place in history. Casey’s Diner is on the National Register of Historic Places. It is also the longest-tenured restaurant in Natick.
So next time you’re in Natick, make sure to stop by Casey’s Diner. Experience a taste of history. Enjoy a “snap” hot dog. Discover why this diner has been a beloved landmark for over a century.