What if these walls could talk? The First Church of Brooklyn has stood here since 1846. It replaced the original church building. That first building was on Cranberry Street.
The First Presbyterian Church of Brooklyn was founded in 1822. Affluent merchants were moving to Brooklyn Heights. They needed a place to worship. This became the first church in Brooklyn Heights. The church even hosted Brooklyn’s official incorporation as a city.
Look up at the 90-foot crenellated tower. Notice the pointed arch windows. This is Gothic Revival architecture. William B. Olmstead designed it. He created a solid and dour building. Some say it’s bold but somewhat naive.
Step closer to the memorial doorway. James Gamble Rogers designed this addition in 1921. The doorway serves as a reminder of the church’s long history.
Many of the stained glass windows were crafted by Louis Comfort Tiffany Studios. These windows add beauty and color. They illuminate the interior with a soft glow.
Now imagine the debates that once echoed within these walls. Dr. Samuel Hanson Cox served as pastor for 17 years. He was an abolitionist. This caused a schism. Some members left to start other churches. Others joined Plymouth Church. Despite the controversy, the First Church of Brooklyn remained strong.
Consider Dr. Charles Cuthbert Hall. He revitalized the church from 1877 to 1897. Membership was declining and debt was severe. Hall brought in over 800 new members. He increased revenues. He made changes to the interior. Raymond Huntington Woodman was hired. He was a gifted organist. Hall established First Church’s prominence in Brooklyn.
Think about the Heights Fellowship. It was started to encourage ecumenism. Racial harmony and internationalism were promoted. This program showcases the church’s commitment to social issues.
The First Presbyterian Church of Brooklyn has faced challenges. Declining finances and low membership occurred. Unstable economic and social conditions arose. Yet, First Church persisted. It embraced its role as a shelter. It engaged in social action. It fostered a multicultural congregation.
Today, the First Church of Brooklyn continues to serve. It stands as a testament to faith and community. Its history is etched in its walls. Its legacy lives on in the hearts of its members. The First Church of Brooklyn stands as a symbol of resilience. It is a landmark in Brooklyn Heights.