Beyond this facade lies a story of faith, resilience, and architectural evolution. This is Saint Johns Church. Today, we stand before a building born from the ashes of a devastating fire.
Saint Johns Church has a fascinating history. The original church on this site was a classical revival structure. But tragedy struck on March 6, 1971 when fire consumed this neighborhood landmark.
From the ruins emerged a new Saint Johns Church. Edgar Tafel, a Frank Lloyd Wright disciple, designed the modern building. This architectural marvel stands as a testament to rebirth and community spirit. The first Eucharist in the new Church of Saint John the Evangelist was celebrated on October 5, 1974. The new building was dedicated on October 1, 1978 by the Rt. Rev. Paul Moore, Jr., Bishop of New York. This modern building was a gift of many parish members, friends, and residents of the community.
But the story of Saint Johns Church extends further back. In 1853, St. Jude’s and a missionary congregation united. They formed the church of Saint John the Evangelist. The first services were held in the Bleecker Building. Later, they moved to the Lecture Room of the Metropolitan Academy.
A group of missionary-minded ladies played a crucial role. They sought to honor the Rt. Rev. Jonathan Mayhew Wainwright. He was the Provisional Bishop of New York. They purchased a Baptist church for this purpose. It became a memorial to Wainwright. The building had a varied past. Originally, it was the Hammond Street Presbyterian Church. Then, it became a Congregational church. Finally, it was the South Baptist Church.
The “Ladies Society for Building a Free Church” bought the building. They gifted it to the congregation of Saint John the Evangelist. In 1856, the first services were held at the Bishop Wainwright Memorial Church. It stood on Hammond Street now West 11th Street and Factory Streets now Waverly Place. The church cleared its debt in 1857. Bishop Horatio Potter consecrated it in 1858.
Over time, Saint Johns Church absorbed other parishes. The Chapel of the Comforter was one. It was known for its parochial school. St. Jude’s Church also merged. Its building became a stained-glass studio and later a movie theater.
Today, Saint Johns Church continues to evolve. It hosts diverse events such as musical performances. These performances enrich the community. Saint Johns Church stands as a symbol of enduring faith. It exemplifies community collaboration. It represents architectural innovation. Take a moment to appreciate the layers of history. Consider the spirit of renewal. This place embodies a vibrant and ever-evolving story.