“Blessed are they who walk in the law of the Lord.” These words above the entrance to St Andrew the Apostle Church whisper a timeless promise. This isn’t just a building. It’s a living testament to faith resilience and the ever-changing face of New York City.
St Andrew’s stands as a proud example of Georgian Revival architecture. It was built in 1939. Maginnis & Walsh and Robert J Reiley designed this magnificent church. It’s the only New York City church designed by the renowned Boston firm Maginnis & Walsh.
The church’s story began much earlier in 1842. Reverend Andrew Byrne founded the parish. Early parishioners worshipped in Carroll Hall. Later they moved into a repurposed Universalist church. That building had a fascinating history. George Washington himself once lived on the site.
Tragedy struck in 1875. A neighboring building collapsed onto St Andrew’s. Five people died. At least 29 were injured. The incident led to building codes being updated. Doors in public buildings now had to open outwards.
St Andrew’s thrived despite setbacks. It became known as “The Printers’ Church”. Father Luke Evers initiated a 2:30 a m Sunday mass. This accommodated the many Catholic workers from nearby Printing House Square. Newspapers like The Sun The New York Telegram The New York Times and The New York World were published there. The “Printers’ Mass” drew other night workers too. Railway workers postal employees and more attended. The tradition lasted for over 50 years.
The church faced demolition threats. In 1890 the city planned a new Municipal Building. The site included St Andrew’s. Archbishop Corrigan successfully fought the plans. The church survived. The threat reappeared in 1911. A new courthouse was planned. Again St Andrew’s was saved.
Finally in 1927 Father Cashin proposed a trade. He offered the church’s property for other land. He envisioned a new church harmonizing with the area’s modern municipal buildings. The new St Andrew’s was dedicated in 1939. It stands today a beacon of faith in the heart of New York City. Its history echoes the city’s own growth and struggles. It’s a place of peace and reflection a reminder of those who walked before us. A place where “Blessed are they who walk in the law of the Lord” rings true.